BreakPoint Blog

Banner
Banner
Personal Communications from God? (Part 1)

Someone claims to have received a personal message directly from God, either audibly or through his or her thoughts. How do you react to this?

Just such a scenario occurred for me last night, when a good friend of mine claimed to have received a prompting from God to avoid a certain entertainment title. I immediately asked him whether he often experiences such communications from the Divine. He replied, "Of course! Don't you?" I answered with an honest no. In fact, I have never received a message from God in this manner. But these days, everyone seems to be a prophet. I have met countless individuals who claim new revelations from the Ruler of the Universe on a daily and hourly basis.

In fact, this seems to have become something of a spiritual vogue among evangelicals. It has crept into our conversation and vocabulary to such a degree, that you commonly hear Christians repeat entire conversations with God which take place inside their heads. The phrases "I heard God say," "God told me," and worst of all, "God wants you to know," regularly crop up in exchanges between believers.

But I think the question deserves asking: Does God really speak to us like this?

Let me be clear that I believe in personal communications from God. In fact, I experience them every time I open the Scriptures. This makes sense to me, since the Bible is the means by which God thoroughly equips His servants for "every good work" (2 Timothy 3:17). In addition, God the Holy Spirit clearly speaks to His elect (both regenerate and unregenerate) alongside His inspired Scripture, opening our hearts and applying each passage to our lives. (See Acts 8).

But does God communicate to individual believers independently of Scripture? The weight of evidence and experience leads me to question deeply, and essentially reject this idea.

Later this week, I will offer a few of the many reasons why this conclusion seems sound.


Comments:

I suppose my reaction would be that it is theoretically possible but that I would be skeptical of most speakers.
God Sounds Like James Earl Jones
Be very careful where you go with this, Shane. I'm well aware that there have always been--and always will be--people who manipulate Christians/Christianity for their own ends. I am also well aware that there are some very sick minds out there who do not know who's voice they hear.

It has been my experience that God loves me passionately, and wants me to love Him to the best of whatever ability He has given me. And so, often, He will initiate conversations with me. They are usually brief and corrective. In fact, they are so brief that I often refer to them as "infused" knowledge or wisdom. What I do NOT get are specific instruction, such as "turn left at the next corner", or "eat Cheerios instead of Corn Chex for breakfast". Nor have I ever heard Him tell me to tell someone else something. Our conversations are intimately personal and so, very private. The only one I talk to about them is my spiritual director, and I haven't even told him every thing!

No, I am not a whacked-out nut-job. Neither am I a cunning, controlling, master-manipulator. One of my parents was both, so I can spot one a block away and side-step them. I am simply a Christian trying my best to follow Jesus, and appreciating His help with my journey.

And no, God does NOT sound like James Earl Jones.
Shane, I'm interested in your future offers.

I have some questions re:
"But does God communicate to individual believers independently of Scripture?"

a) You mean, aside from Jesus when he was on earth?
b) Do you believe God can communicate to people who have never heard the gospel? (e.g. Dreams in Muslim countries)
c) Are you a Cessationist?

"The weight of evidence and experience leads me to question deeply, and essentially reject this idea."

d) I think it's dangerous to accept people saying they have some kind of new "revelation". But I'm not quite with you on rejecting this idea. For instance, does God communicate with us when a fellow believer encourages us? or shows us love? Are you saying Scripture has to be quoted for this to be God working through his body?

Thanks.
I look forward to reading your Part 2 when I return from vacation, Shane. I hope you'll distinguish clearly between what God can do, and what some Christians will tell you He does.

Because if God wants to knock Saul off his horse and speak out loud to him, making him into St. Paul, then I believe God certainly could. It's that whole "omnipotence" thingy.

But does God whisper constantly in the ears of some believers "No, not the chocolate donut; take the bran muffin!" Of that, I'm quite skeptical. To tell everyone that this constantly happens to you, well, that sounds like "holier than thou" bragging, to me. Wouldn't God prefer we be humble?

And should we rely on voices in our head, when we have a whole Bible full of instruction? That would be like never reading the driver's manual, and replying on the traffic cop to tell you what to do; it's certainly do-able, but not very mature - or safe!

Those are my paltry thoughts. Alas, I'll have to wait for what I have every sincere confidence will be your far more refined exposition.
I believe like anything, the use of claiming personal communication from God can be greatly misused. My first experience with this was in college, when a guy broke up with me because God told him to. Truly, I know now, many years later, that this was not a relationship that was meant to last. But it seemed like such a cop-out, and I wonder if to him it seemed like an air-tight case. I mean, who could argue with God?!?